Allegations of Research Misconduct

Last updated: 13 November 2026

G&R takes every allegation of research or publication misconduct seriously, whether it concerns a submitted manuscript or a published article, and whether it is raised by an author, reader, reviewer, editor or institution. G&R handles allegations under the COPE Core Practices and the relevant COPE flowcharts.

1. What counts as misconduct

Type

Examples

Fabrication and falsification

Inventing data or cases; altering data, images or quotations to change their meaning

Plagiarism

Using others' text, data or ideas without credit, including translated text and recycled text from the authors' own published work without disclosure

Duplicate or redundant publication

Publishing the same work, or substantially the same work, in more than one place without disclosure

Authorship misconduct

Gift, guest or ghost authorship; adding or removing authors without agreement; buying or selling authorship

Citation manipulation

Citing or asking others to cite work mainly to raise citation counts, by authors, reviewers or editors

Peer review manipulation

Fake reviewer identities, reviews written by or for the authors, review rings

Undisclosed conflicts of interest

Hiding financial or personal interests that affect the work

Unethical research

Research involving people without ethics approval or informed consent, or that breaches participants' privacy

Misuse of generative AI

Undisclosed use, or AI-generated data, references or content presented as the authors' own work

Honest error and differences of interpretation are not misconduct; they are handled as corrections.

2. How to report a concern

Write to gresilience@journal.dealingsfoundation.com / info@dealingspublishing.com with:

  • the manuscript ID or the article's title and DOI;
  • what you believe is wrong, with specific evidence (pages, figures, links to the original source);
  • your name and contact details, and any interest you have in the matter.

Anonymous reports are considered if they contain enough specific evidence to be checked. If the concern is about the Editor-in-Chief, or about an editor who would normally handle it, write to the publisher at info@dealingspublishing.com, marked for the Senior Publishing Advisor. The Editor-in-Chief, who is also the founder of the publisher, takes no part in such cases.

3. How G&R handles it

Step

What happens

Target time

1. Acknowledgement

The editorial office confirms receipt

7 days

2. Initial assessment

An editor with no conflict checks whether the concern is specific, falls within this policy and is supported by evidence. Clearly unfounded reports are closed, and the reporter is told why

21 days

3. Response from the authors

The corresponding author is given the concern and evidence and asked to respond on behalf of all authors

21 days to respond

4. Assessment

The editor reviews the response and may consult reviewers, independent experts or COPE. Where the evidence points to serious misconduct, the editor asks the authors' institution to investigate

Usually 60 days from receipt; longer if an institution investigates

5. Decision

The editor decides on the outcome and informs the authors and, where appropriate, the reporter

With step 4

Review of a submitted manuscript is paused while an allegation about it is assessed.

4. Possible outcomes

  • No misconduct found: the case is closed; a clarification or correction may still be published.
  • Submitted manuscript: rejection, and in serious cases notification of the authors' institution.
  • Published article: correction, expression of concern or retraction, under the Correction and Retraction Policy.
  • Reviewers or editors: removal from the reviewer database or the editorial team.
  • Serious or repeated cases: G&R may decline further submissions from the people involved for a stated period.

5. Fairness and confidentiality

  • Authors are told about the concern and always have the chance to respond before a decision.
  • The reporter's identity is not revealed to the authors without the reporter's consent. People who raise concerns in good faith are not disadvantaged in their own dealings with G&R.
  • Information about a case is shared only with those who need it to resolve it.
  • Knowingly false or malicious allegations are themselves treated as misconduct.

6. Appeals

Authors may appeal a decision once, within 30 days, with new evidence or a reason to believe the process was not followed. The appeal is handled by an editor or publisher representative who took no part in the original decision, under the appeals procedure in the Peer Review Process.